Oklahoma’s Oldest
Law Firm

Can you be convicted solely on circumstantial evidence?

On Behalf of | Aug 20, 2023 | Criminal Defense |

Circumstantial evidence does not directly establish a fact in question but provides a basis for a reasonable inference that the fact likely exists. It relies on logical connections and surrounding circumstances to draw conclusions rather than providing explicit proof that links the accused to the crime.

Picture a burglary case where fingerprints matching the accused were found on the window sill of the crime scene. Security footage also captured the accused loitering suspiciously near the premises before the incident. Although no direct witness saw the accused enter, the circumstantial evidence—matching fingerprints and suspicious behavior—creates a reasonable inference that the accused was likely involved in the burglary.

Can a person be convicted based solely on such evidence? The short answer is yes. Circumstantial evidence alone can be sufficient to secure a conviction. Remember, all the prosecution has to do is prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If the evidence convincingly demonstrates your involvement in the crime and leaves no viable alternative explanation, it can lead to a guilty verdict.

The law in Oklahoma on circumstantial evidence

The use of circumstantial evidence in Oklahoma criminal proceedings is permissible, and convictions based solely on such evidence have occurred. The general rule with circumstantial evidence is that the facts shown must be consistent with and point to the defendant’s guilt. They must also be inconsistent with their innocence.

The importance of a strong defense

You can challenge the reliability, relevance and competence of circumstantial evidence, just like you would other forms of evidence. For example, you could raise reasonable doubt and weaken the prosecution’s case by providing alternative explanations to the circumstantial evidence against you. Having experienced legal guidance can help craft a practical defense based on the prevailing facts and increase the chances of a favorable outcome.